Bre Petrunko copyright dispute: YouTube’s Bre Petrunko Dispute Shows the Cost
The Bre Petrunko copyright dispute ended with YouTube restoring Samantha Shokin’s recording after Media Nov Records withdrew its takedown request.

Bre Petrunko copyright dispute — YouTube restored Samantha Shokin’s recording of the folk song “Bre Petrunko” after Media Nov Records withdrew its copyright removal request, ending a dispute that exposed how
- The Bre Petrunko copyright dispute ended with YouTube restoring Shokin’s recording after Media Nov Records withdrew its takedown request.
- Shokin said she recorded her own performance of a public-domain folk song, but YouTube rejected two counterclaims before the claimant changed course.
- Media Nov told 404 Media that it operates 500 YouTube channels and uses automated rights-management tools.
What changed
Shokin’s video returned to YouTube after Media Nov Records retracted the request that had removed it. A YouTube spokesperson confirmed the reinstatement followed the claimant’s withdrawal, according to 404 Media’s reporting.
The recording began as a short cover Shokin made during the pandemic and first posted to SoundCloud. She later uploaded it to YouTube, where it reached 125,000 views over four years. After DJs began using her voice in other tracks, Shokin learned that a sample pack sold by Loopmasters included her performance; the distributor apologized and granted her royalties.
The later takedown was a separate problem. Media Nov filed a copyright claim against Shokin’s original YouTube video, and the platform removed it. Shokin submitted two counterclaims, but YouTube declined both and directed her to contact the claimant.
Media Nov initially asked Shokin for evidence that she had recorded the song. After 404 Media sought comment, the company said it would retract the removal request, while also stating that it did not consider the video’s removal necessary because it had generated no revenue or views. It added that the withdrawal did not waive any rights and said it intended to pursue legal proceedings over the underlying copyright dispute.
The source for this report is 404 Media’s account, including statements from Shokin, Media Nov Records, YouTube, and copyright lawyer Alfred Steiner. Its reporting describes the dispute and the company’s response; it does not establish that a court has resolved any broader rights question.
Why the Bre Petrunko copyright dispute matters
For musicians, a YouTube copyright strike can affect access to a recording they uploaded themselves. Shokin’s experience shows how a claim can remove a video before an uploader gets a clear explanation or a useful way to reach the claimant.
That pressure matters even when a creator believes the claim is mistaken. Shokin said she could not get a human response through her attempts to contact YouTube and Media Nov, and two counterclaims did not restore the recording. In this case, the video returned only after Media Nov withdrew its request.
The rights involved also require care. “Bre Petrunko” is described as an old folk song with no known writer, while Philip Koutev popularized a version in 1963. The source says the Smithsonian holds copyright in that particular version. Those details do not, on their own, establish who owns Shokin’s recording or settle what rights a claimant may hold in a particular arrangement.
Steiner told 404 Media that submitting a takedown request without holding the relevant rights can create legal liability, including damages and legal costs. He also warned that smaller creators may struggle to obtain a remedy when a claimant is difficult to identify or pursue. That is his assessment, not a finding in a court case.
Who is affected
Independent musicians and other YouTube uploaders face the most direct risk when automated copyright systems act on claims they believe are inaccurate. Shokin had her original audio and a history of publishing it, yet YouTube rejected her counterclaims before the claimant withdrew.
Producers and DJs can also be caught up in unclear rights chains. Shokin found that her voice had reached a sample pack sold by Loopmasters and had been used in multiple tracks. The distributor apologized and granted her royalties, but that earlier resolution did not prevent the later claim against her YouTube upload.
Platforms and rights-management companies are part of the same chain. YouTube processes copyright complaints through automated systems, while Media Nov describes itself as a distribution and rights-management business. The case raises a practical question for both: how can a creator quickly challenge a claim and reach someone who can examine the actual recording?
404 Media found four YouTube pages managed by Media Nov, each with hundreds of videos, and reported that the company said it operated 500 channels. It described many uploads as low-effort electronic music and AI-generated visuals. That account provides context about the company’s activity, but it does not prove that any specific automated system caused the claim against Shokin.
What to watch next
Readers should watch for whether Media Nov follows through on its stated intention to pursue legal proceedings. The source does not report that a lawsuit was filed, and its statement that it would take legal action does not show what any future case might decide.
Another unresolved point is which work Media Nov believes triggered its claim. 404 Media asked the company to identify the song or work in its catalog behind the notice, but it did not answer that question. Without that explanation, the exact basis of the claim remains unclear.
The platform process also deserves attention. Shokin’s video came back after the claimant withdrew the request, not because the source reports that YouTube independently resolved the underlying rights dispute. Readers can follow the related YouTube update on Shokin’s restored folk song for the platform outcome.
More broadly, the case leaves creators with a concrete issue to monitor: whether complaint systems provide a workable route to challenge claims before a video disappears for an extended period. The reporting documents Shokin’s difficulty reaching people, but it does not establish how often similar disputes occur across YouTube.
Frequently asked questions
Why did YouTube remove Samantha Shokin’s “Bre Petrunko” video?
Media Nov Records filed a copyright removal request, and YouTube took the video down. The source does not identify the specific catalog work that Media Nov said prompted its claim.
How did Shokin’s video return to YouTube?
Media Nov withdrew its removal request, and YouTube restored the video afterward. Shokin’s two counterclaims had not succeeded before the withdrawal.
Is “Bre Petrunko” a public-domain song?
404 Media describes it as an old folk song with no known writer. It also reports that copyright in Philip Koutev’s particular version belongs to the Smithsonian, so the status of that version should not be confused with every recording or arrangement of the song.
Related on TechnoRapper
- YouTube update on Shokin’s restored folk song
- Meta Italy fine: Meta’s Italy Fine Puts Instagram Photo Access Under Scrutiny
- Magic Star Trek plans: Magic: The Gathering Has No Current Plans for Another
- Doctor Doom plans: Avengers: Doomsday’s Doctor Doom Turn Began Before
- Victoria Pedretti Mystique: Victoria Pedretti Emerges as a Mystique Possibility
Inspired by: 404 Media
How we used the source: facts, quotes, and numbers in this article come only from that Inspired by link. We added structure, search intent, and reader context. We did not independently verify the reporting.
Permanent link · https://technorapper.com/2026/11/bre-petrunko-copyright-dispute/