YouTube copyright claim: YouTube Restores Samantha Shokin’s Folk Song After a
A YouTube copyright claim removed Samantha Shokin’s folk-song recording. The video returned after Media Nov Records withdrew its request.

YouTube copyright claim — YouTube restored Samantha Shokin’s recording of the public-domain folk song “Bre Petrunko” after Media Nov Records withdrew its copyright removal request. The dispute shows how an
- YouTube copyright claim: YouTube restored Samantha Shokin’s recording after Media Nov Records withdrew its takedown request.
- Shokin’s own performance of the folk song had been struck after her voice appeared in a sample pack and tracks made by other musicians.
- The dispute highlights the difficulty creators can face when automated copyright systems leave them without a clear path to reach a human reviewer.
What changed: YouTube reversed the copyright claim
YouTube restored Shokin’s video around a day after Media Nov Records withdrew its complaint, according to reporting by 404 Media. The claim had removed her recording of “Bre Petrunko,” a Bulgarian folk song, despite Shokin’s attempt to challenge the takedown through YouTube’s counter-notification process.
The events began with a short performance Shokin recorded during the pandemic and first posted to SoundCloud. She later uploaded it to YouTube, where the video accumulated 125,000 views over four years. The recording became more widely used after DJs and electronic musicians sampled her voice.
Shokin traced the samples to a Loopmasters collection called “Folk Legends,” which included her version of the song. Loopmasters apologized and granted her royalties from the sample pack, according to the account. That appeared to settle one part of the matter, but the original YouTube recording remained vulnerable to a separate dispute.
Last month, Media Nov Records filed a copyright removal request, and YouTube took the video down. Shokin filed two counterclaims, but YouTube declined them and directed her to contact the claimant. She and Loopmasters tried to reach Media Nov, but the company did not respond to them at first.
After 404 Media contacted the company, Media Nov asked Shokin for evidence that she had made the recording. It then said it would retract its removal request, explaining that the video had not generated revenue or views and that keeping it down was unnecessary at that stage. The company also said the withdrawal did not waive any rights it might hold and mentioned possible legal proceedings.
Media Nov disputed the basis of Shokin’s position by distinguishing rights in the song or arrangement from rights in a particular sound recording. “Bre Petrunko” is an old folk song with no known writer, while composer Philip Koutev popularized a version in 1963; the copyright to that specific version is held by the Smithsonian, 404 Media reported. Shokin’s complaint, however, concerned her voice and performance in her own recording.
Why it matters: copyright claims can outpace human review
Analysis: A takedown can affect a creator even when the underlying dispute is confused or concerns different rights. In Shokin’s case, the distinction between a folk composition, an arrangement, and her particular recording became central, yet YouTube initially removed the video and rejected her counterclaims.
YouTube relies on automated systems to process copyright claims, and the report says claims tend to receive automatic approval. That structure can make the claimant’s action powerful while leaving the uploader to navigate a process that may not quickly connect them with a person who can assess the details.
The dispute also shows how one recording can travel through several layers of distribution. Shokin’s voice appeared in a commercial sample pack and then in tracks by DJs and producers; meanwhile, the YouTube video containing her original performance faced a claim from a company that said it held rights related to the musical content.
404 Media reported that Media Nov said it operated 500 YouTube channels, many publishing low-view electronic music videos and AI-generated artwork. Artist and copyright lawyer Alfred Steiner told the publication that a company using automated tools to identify music could issue takedowns beyond the rights it actually holds. That is his assessment, not a finding about every claim made by the company.
Who is affected: independent musicians and video creators
Independent musicians are directly affected when a platform removes their work and the process does not resolve their claim. Shokin said she could not get a response from YouTube or Media Nov through her own efforts, and she described the experience as a system failure.
Creators whose work enters sample libraries also have an interest in knowing how their recordings are licensed and credited. Shokin received royalties after Loopmasters investigated, but she said DJs and producers had already been using her voice without her knowledge. The later takedown created a different problem: a company claimed control over content that included her performance.
Platforms and music distributors are part of the same chain. YouTube controlled whether the video remained available, while Loopmasters helped identify how Shokin’s recording had reached other musicians and attempted to contact Media Nov. The case illustrates why clear rights information and usable dispute channels matter to each party.
What to watch next
The immediate outcome is clear: YouTube reinstated Shokin’s video after Media Nov withdrew its removal request. What remains unresolved is whether Media Nov will pursue the legal action it mentioned or explain which specific work in its catalog prompted the original claim. 404 Media said the company did not answer its question about that work.
Readers should also watch whether the dispute prompts a clearer explanation of how claims against recordings of public-domain songs are reviewed. The source does not report any platform policy change, so it remains uncertain whether Shokin’s case will affect YouTube’s broader process.
For creators, the practical lesson supported by this case is to retain original audio and documentation that can help establish when and how a recording was made. Shokin had original files and a history with a distributor, yet those materials did not prevent the initial removal or quickly resolve the counterclaims.
Frequently asked questions
Why did YouTube remove Samantha Shokin’s “Bre Petrunko” video?
Media Nov Records filed a copyright removal request, and YouTube took the video down. Shokin challenged the decision, but YouTube declined her two counterclaims before Media Nov withdrew its request.
Is “Bre Petrunko” a public-domain song?
404 Media describes it as an old folk song with no known writer. The report distinguishes the folk song from a version popularized by Philip Koutev in 1963, whose copyright is held by the Smithsonian.
Was Shokin’s YouTube recording restored?
Yes. Media Nov withdrew its complaint, and a YouTube spokesperson confirmed that the platform reinstated the video. Media Nov said the withdrawal did not waive any rights it might hold.
Related on TechnoRapper
- Apple TV video podcasts: Apple TV Adds a Free-to-Watch Video Podcasts Section
- FAA Communications Failure Disrupts Flights After Router Problem
- Amazon James Bond: Amazon’s First James Bond Film Casts Robert Pattinson
- Google Maps AI itineraries: Google Maps Adds AI Itineraries for Day Trips and
- drone delivery PTSD: Amazon’s Drone Delivery Expansion Raises a PTSD Concern
Inspired by: 404 Media
How we used the source: facts, quotes, and numbers in this article come only from that Inspired by link. We added structure, search intent, and reader context. We did not independently verify the reporting.
Permanent link · https://technorapper.com/2026/11/youtube-copyright-claim/